Guide · By Alif, True & Level · Updated 2 October 2026

Lead sites or your own website: where should trade firms spend?

A lead from a quote site often goes to several firms at once, so you're competing on price before you've even rung. An enquiry from your own website comes to you alone, but it takes months to build up. Most roofing and building firms use a mix of both, plus a directory listing. Here's a fair look at what each route costs you and what it's good for.

We help firms get found online for a living, so we're not neutral. We've tried to be fair anyway, and the answer for most firms is "a mix", not "only us".

1. Pay-per-lead and quote sites

Sites where homeowners post a job and tradespeople pay to contact them, either per lead or with credits.

Good for

• Filling gaps in the diary quickly.
• Firms just starting out, with no reviews or website yet.
• Costs you can switch on and off week by week.

Watch out for

• Shared leads. The same job is often sent to several firms, so you're competing on price from the first call.
• You pay whether or not you win. Track your win rate, not just the number of leads.
• Rented, not owned. When you stop paying, the work stops.

2. Membership directories

Vetted directories where you pay a membership fee to be listed, often with checks and customer reviews shown on your profile.

Good for

• Trust. A vetted badge and a page of reviews reassures careful buyers.
• Reviews in one place that homeowners already know how to read.
• Being found by people who start their search on the directory itself.

Watch out for

• Minimum terms. Check how long you're committing to before you sign.
• Competitors on the same page. The directory shows other firms alongside you.
• Your reviews live on their site. If you leave, your profile goes with it.

3. Your own website (and Google profile)

Pages on your own site about the jobs you do in the towns you cover, plus your free Google Business Profile.

Good for

• Enquiries that come to you alone. Nobody else is sent the same lead.
• Owned, not rented. Pages keep working after you stop paying anyone to build them.
• Bigger jobs. People researching a new roof or a loft conversion read your work and choose you, rather than comparing three quick quotes.
• AI search. ChatGPT and Google's AI answers mostly learn about local firms from websites and listings.

Watch out for

• It's slow. New pages usually take a couple of months to start bringing in calls. It's not a quick fix for a quiet month.
• It needs real material. Good pages need your photos, job details and prices. Without them, it's just words.
• Quality varies hugely. See our guide on what SEO should cost and what you should get.

So which should you choose?

• Diary empty this month? Lead sites are the fastest tap to turn on.
• No reviews yet? A vetted directory and your Google profile build trust quickly.
• Want bigger jobs and less price competition over the next year? Your own website is where that comes from, and it keeps paying back.

Most established firms do best with a mix: a directory or Google profile for trust, their own website for the bigger jobs, and lead sites only to fill gaps. Whatever you choose, ask every new customer "how did you find us?" and write it down. After three months you'll know exactly which route pays.

More guides for trade firms →